Baltimore Review contributor honors
Pushcart prize
| 2015 | Matthew Neill Null | Special Mention |
Best American Essays
| 2014 | Noreen McAuliffe | Notable |
| 2015 | Michelle Bracken | Notable |
| 2018 | Ruby Al-Qasem | Notable |
| 2022 | Susan Messer | Notable |
| 2022 | Caroline Miller | Notable |
| 2023 | Lucinda Cummings | Notable |
Best American Short Stories
| 2024 | Frank Reilly | Other Distinguished Stories of 2023 |
| 2024 | Katherine Tunning | Other Distinguished Stories of 2023 |
Best of the Net
| 2012 | Catherine Parnell | Fiction winner list |
| 2012 | Leslie Tucker | Nonfiction winner list |
| 2013 | Megan Grumbling | Poetry winner list |
| 2013 | Joanna Pearson | Poetry finalist list |
| 2014 | Ash Bowen | Poetry winner list |
| 2016 | Sarah Giragosian | Poetry winner list |
| 2017 | Gail Morton | Poetry finalist list |
| 2018 | Threa Almontaser | Poetry winner list |
| 2018 | Sarah Carlson | Poetry finalist list |
| 2018 | Ruby Al-Qasem | Nonfiction finalist list |
| 2019 | Zach VandeZande | Fiction finalist list |
| 2020 | Naomi Cohn | Nonfiction finalist list |
| 2020 | Joshua Martin | Poetry finalist list |
| 2022 | Claire O’Connor | Fiction finalist list |
| 2022 | Maria Zoccola | Fiction finalist list |
| 2022 | Lance Larsen | Poetry finalist list |
| 2025 | Jessica Hammack | Poetry finalist list |
Million Writers Award
| 2016 | Annie Reid | 3rd Place Winner |
PEN/Robert J. Dau Prize for Emerging Writers
| 2018 | Drew McCutchen | Winner of $2,000 prize |
| 2018 | Elinam Agbo | Winner of $2,000 prize |
Best Small Fictions
| 2017 | Nick Almeida | Included in anthology |
| 2022 | Basmah Sakrani | Included in anthology |
| 2022 | Nicholas Maistros | Included in anthology |
| 2023 | Matt Barrett | Included in anthology |
| 2023 | Hilal Isler | Included in anthology |
| 2024 | Joshua Jones Lofflin | Included in anthology |
Best Microfiction
| 2021 | Avra Margariti | Included in anthology |
| 2023 | Christopher Notarnicola | Included in anthology |
| 2026 | Christopher Notarnicola | Included in anthology |
The Wigleaf Top 50 Very Short Fictions
| 2023 | Melissa Faustine Chang | Longlist |
| 2023 | Kent Kosack | Longlist |
| 2024 | Cressida Blake Roe | Top 50 |
| 2025 | Jared Johnson | Longlist |
| 2025 | Rukman Ragas | Longlist |